Why office‑to‑residential pencils in Phoenix
We bought two Class A office towers in North Phoenix in September 2024 and we are turning them into Class A apartments. Since then the question I get most often, from brokers and from capital alike, is some version of: why conversion instead of ground-up?
The answer is usually replacement cost, which is plain arithmetic and less interesting than people expect.
What you are buying
On a conversion, the land, the structure and the parking are already there, and you are buying them at a basis that reflects what happened to office demand after the 2020 COVID hybrid work-from-home implosion. Construction costs to build new commercial properties have not fallen. So you have two lines moving in opposite directions, and the whole opportunity is the spread between them.
I have been in this business for thirty-eight years and I have rarely seen a gap like the one between what Class A commercial assets trade for today and what it would cost to build them. When you can buy standing structure well below what the same building would cost to replace, you have a margin that doesn’t depend on rents doing anything heroic, because the number you are underwriting already exists. Additionally, we end up providing a steel and concrete building of a quality that the tenants may never have lived in otherwise. Also, many of the midrise buildings have amazing views. We call this, in part, our Attainable Luxury.
You cannot build that today for what it costs to buy it.
The part that kills deals
The hard part of a conversion is the floor plate.
Office buildings were designed around a different problem. They were built to put as many desks as possible within reach of an elevator core, which can produce deep floors where the middle is a long way from any window. Housing has the opposite requirement: every suite needs windows, and a leasable unit needs light on a real elevation.
So on any given building the question is whether the plate can be cut into units that people will pay to live in. Sometimes it can, either as it stands or once you carve a light well or take a bite out of the slab. Sometimes the geometry simply does not allow it, and no pro forma will change that. This is a design problem before it becomes a construction problem. Most conversion deals die here, months and a good deal of money after somebody decided the basis looked attractive.
We test the plate before we get excited about the price. A building priced low because it cannot be converted is not cheap. If we have some interior dead space, we won’t pay for it. However, we will turn this into storage, small game rooms or even a full gym.
What this looks like on our site
Canyon Corporate Plaza is 315,000 square feet across two towers on 18 acres, with two parking structures and roughly six acres of additional zoned land. When we are finished there will be 363 homes on that site from the conversion itself. There will be new construction of another 350 ground-up units on additional land we already control.
That mix matters, and I would point it out to anyone looking at their first conversion. The structure gives you speed and basis, and the surplus land gives you scale. A site that offers both is worth considerably more than the two parts separately, because the new construction uses infrastructure the conversion has already paid to bring in.
Parking is the other asset people overlook. Structured parking is expensive and slow to build, and a suburban office campus is usually over-parked by residential standards. Inheriting it removes one of the largest line items from a ground-up multifamily budget, and one of the harder things to get approved. In fact, we have so much unneeded parking that we are building 93 homes in and on top of the four-story parking structure.
Two caveats
Conversion is faster than ground-up, but not as fast as everyone thinks. You still have to entitle it and fix whatever the previous owner deferred, and you will open a wall and find something no drawing predicted. We handle that by carrying our own construction team, which is a subject in itself.
A good basis is also no substitute for a business plan. You still have to make the building work for the people who will live in it, and they do not care what you paid. If the units are dark, the corridors feel like an office or the amenity spaces read as a converted lobby, the basis will not save you. It only means you can afford to solve those problems properly.
Phase 1 at Canyon Corporate Plaza is in development. The detail is on the projects page.